Girl Scout cookies are no doubt one of the most iconic snacks of all time, but there’s always debate about which ones really deserve the top spots. Every year people act like their favorite is untouchable, and every year someone gets exposed for having mid taste. Some cookies carry the brand, others just ride the hype. Here are the top five Girl Scout cookies:
5. Do-si-dos
Do-si-dos are the sleeper pick that not everyone talks about, but they always deliver. The peanut butter sandwich with oatmeal cookies gives it a slightly more “mature” taste. They’re not flashy, but they get the job done every time.
4. S’mores
S’mores didn’t stick around, but they absolutely deserve a spot on this list. They had that graham cracker, chocolate, marshmallow combo that was so good. Lowkey is one of the most unique Girl Scout cookies ever, and it’s a shame they got discontinued.
3. Samoas
Coconut, caramel, chocolate, all stacked together. Some people hate coconut, but if you don’t, these are easily elite. However, they can’t touch the top two.
2. Thin Mints
Thin Mints are the most consistent cookie in the lineup. Whether they’re frozen or straight out the box, they never miss. The chocolate and mint combo is clean, simple, and somehow always better than you remember.
1. Tagalongs
Tagalongs take the top spot and it’s not really close. Peanut butter and chocolate is already a top-tier combo, and the crunchy cookie base just makes it better. They’re the perfect balance of everything, and they disappear faster than any other box.
Bringing back S’mores would instantly shake up the rankings, but Tagalongs are still holding that #1 spot no matter what.
